The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works: An Essay in the Philosophy of Music

By Lydia Goehr

What's desirous about the composition, functionality, and reception of classical song? What are we doing after we hearken to this tune heavily? Why while enjoying a Beethoven sonata do performers start with the 1st notice indicated within the ranking; why do not they be happy to improvise round the sonata's important subject? Why, ultimately, does it move opposed to culture for an viewers at a live performance of classical tune to faucet its ft? certain up in those questions is the overriding query of what it ability philosophically, musically, and traditionally for musicians to discuss tune by way of "works".

In this e-book, Lydia Goehr describes how the concept that of a musical paintings absolutely crystallized round 1800, and in this case outlined the norms, expectancies, and behavioral styles that experience come to symbolize classical musical perform. the outline is decided within the context of a extra basic philosophical account of the increase and fall of strategies and beliefs, and in their normative services; even as, debates among conductors, early-music performers, and avant-gardists are addressed.

The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works is a seminal paintings of scholarship, and has seemed in an mind-blowing number of contexts and disciplines from musicological and philosophical due to the fact that its preliminary e-book. This moment version incorporates a new Introductory Essay through the writer, discussing the genesis of her groundbreaking thesis, how her next paintings has and built comparable topics, and the way criticisms alongside the best way have proficient not just her personal paintings however the "Imaginary Museum" thought extra mostly because it unfold throughout disciplinary strains. A provocative foreword by way of Richard Taruskin contextualizes Goehr's argument and issues to its carrying on with centrality to the field.

Show description

Quick preview of The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works: An Essay in the Philosophy of Music PDF

Show sample text content

What, we have to find out now, had this reconceptualization concerned about functional phrases? How did the romantic aesthetic impact in useful phrases the emergence of the work-concept? What had perform appeared like prior to that emergence and what did it seem like afterwards? What bearing did that emergence have at the roles of the composer, performer, listener, and critic, as those have been at the same time being redefined in daily musical perform? 239 Either/Or, tr. D. F. Swenson and L. M. Swenson (Princeton, 1944), fifty five.

See what I name Case 2 lower than. Levinson additionally characterizes the excellence among implicit and non-implicit kinds by way of a contrast among constructions and buildings. ‘The Brooklyn Bridge didn't exist ahead of its development. however the geometrical constitution it embodies, which required and obtained no building, has consistently existed’ (8 n. 9). A PLATONIST concept OF MUSICAL WORKS forty nine Levinson distinguishes implicit varieties, whose life is taken to pre-date or to exist ahead of any specific inventive task, from these varieties whose id depends on components having to do with the way and time in their initiation.

134 THE historic procedure of tools centuries previous, whilst he declared with slicing nuance that ‘one type of tune makes use of tools and one other produces poetry’. one hundred sixty five since it was once commonly authorised, in addition, even within the later heart a while, textual content may possibly and may influence the composition of an accompanying musical constitution, it was once hardly stated that the influence should still or maybe may paintings the opposite direction around. whilst it was once, because it more and more got here to be, the acknowledgement used to be installed the shape of a criticism, that phrases are not any longer handled as basic yet as mere pretexts for musical composition (narrowly conceived as a composition of sounds).

Spotting anything to be an awesome signifies that it's hardly if ever completely discovered, yet this doesn't undermine its life and strength in anyway. If ideal compliance is a perfect of musical perform, it can't even be a prerequisite for functionality individuation. to determine it as such will be to invite an excessive amount of of the perform; it might be to over-determine it. In different phrases, it might be a mistake to specify excellent compliance as an id situation for a functionality of a musical paintings. 124 targeting beliefs paves easy methods to an figuring out of functionality individuation.

Each one paintings hence required a type of fake awareness at the a part of the general public for it to outlive and serve as within the manner conceived for it. artistic artists must exhibit their independence from their creations by way of interfering with and destroying the impact that their works have been created by means of human palms, and in 213 Hegel, Aesthetics, 25–6. 214 Hector Berlioz, ‘Concert de Richard Wagner: los angeles Musique de l'avenir’, A travers chant: Ëtudes musicales: Adorations, boutades et opinions, second edn.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.65 of 5 – based on 49 votes